criminal psychology-第139章
按键盘上方向键 ← 或 → 可快速上下翻页，按键盘上的 Enter 键可回到本书目录页，按键盘上方向键 ↑ 可回到本页顶部！
————未阅读完？加入书签已便下次继续阅读！
altogether believed； simply because it was assumed that the punch was so vigorous that the wounded man saw sparks by the light of which he could recognize the other。 And yet already Aristotle knew that such sparks are only subjective。 But that such things were believed is a notable warning。＇1＇
＇1＇ For literature of Edmund Parish： ber Trugwahrnehmung。 Leipsig 1894。 A Cramer： Geriehtliche Psychiatrie。 Jena 1897。 Th。 Lipps： sthetische Eindrcke u。 optische。 Taschung。 J。 Sully： Illusions； London； 1888。
Section 99。 （2） _Optical Illusions_。
It will be best to begin the study of optical illusions with the consideration of those conditions which cause extraordinary； lunatic images。 They are important because the illusion is recognizable with respect to the possibility of varied interpretations by any observer； and because anybody may experiment for himself with a bit of paper on the nature of false optical apprehension。 If we should demonstrate no more than that the simplest conditions often involve coarse mistakes； much will have been accomplished for the law； since the ‘‘irrefutable evidence'' of our senses would then show itself to need corroboration。 Nothing is proved with ‘‘I have seen it myself；'' for a mistake in one point shows the equal possibility of mistakes in all other points。
Generally； it may be said that the position of lines is not without influence on the estimation of their size。＇2＇ Perpendicular dimensions are taken to be somewhat greater than they are。 Of two crossed lines； the vertical one seems longer； although it is really equal to the horizontal one。 An oblong； lying on its somewhat longer side； is taken to be a square； if we set it on the shorter side it seems to be still more oblong than it really is。 If we divide a square into equal angles we take the nearer horizontal ones to be larger； so that we often take an angle of thirty degrees to be forty…five。 Habit has much influence here。 It will hardly be believed； and certainly is not consciously known； that in the letter S the upper curve has a definitely smaller radius than the lower one； but the inverted S shows this at once。 To such types other false estimations belong： inclinations； roofs； etc。； appear so steep in the distance that it is said to be impossible to move on them without especial help。 But whoever does move on them finds the inclination not at all so great。 Hence； it is necessary； whenever the ascension of some inclined plane is declared impossible； to inquire whether the author of the declaration was himself there； or whether he had judged the thing at a distance。
＇2＇ Cf。 Lotze： Medizinische Psychologie。 Leipzig 1852。
Slight crooks are underestimated。 Exner＇1＇ rightly calls attention to the fact that in going round the rotunda of the Viennese Prater； he always reached the exit much sooner than he expected。 This is due to the presence of slight deviations and on them are based the numerous false estimates of distance and the curious fact that people； on being lost at night in the woods； go round in a significantly small circle。 It is frequently observed that persons； who for one reason or another； i。 e。； robbery； maltreatment； a burglarious assault； etc。； had fled into the woods to escape； found themselves at daybreak； in spite of their flight； very near the place of the crime； so that their honesty in fleeing seems hardly believable。 Nevertheless it may be perfectly trustworthy； even though in the daytime the fugitive might be altogether at home in the woods。 He has simply underestimated the deviations he has made； and hence believes that he has moved at most in a very flat arc。 Supposing himself to be going forward and leaving the wood； he has really been making a sharp arc； and always in the same direction； so that his path has really been circular。
＇1＇ Cf。 Entwurf； etc。
Some corroboration for this illusion is supplied by the fact that the left eye sees objects on the left too small； while the right eye underestimates the right side of objects。 This underestimation varies from 0。3 to 0。7％。 These are magnitudes which may naturally be of importance； and which in the dark most affect deviations that are closely regarded on the inner side of the eyei。 e。； deviations to the left of the left eye or the right of the right eye。
Such confusions become most troublesome when other estimations are added to them。 So long as the informant knows that he has only been estimating； the danger is not too great。 But as a rule the informant does not regard his conception as an estimate； but as certain knowledge。 He does not say； ‘‘I estimate；'' he says； ‘‘It is so。'' Aubert tells how the astronomer Frster had a number of educated men； physicians； etc。； estimate the diameter of the moon。 The estimation varied from 1'' to 8'' and more。 The proper diameter is 1。5'' at a distance of 12''。
It is well known that an unfurnished room seems much smaller than a furnished one； and a lawn covered with snow； smaller than a thickly…grown one。 We are regularly surprised when we find an enormous new structure on an apparently small lot； or when a lot is parcelled out into smaller building lots。 When they are planked off we marvel at the number of planks which can be laid on the sur… face。 The illusions are still greater when we look upward。 We are less accustomed to estimation of verticals than of horizontals。 An object on the gutter of a roof seems much smaller than at a similar distance on the ground。 This can be easily observed if any figure which has been on the roof of a house for years is once brought down。 Even if it is horizontally twice as far as the height of the house； the figure still seems larger than before。 That this illusion is due to defective practice is shown by the fact that children make mistakes which adults find inconceivable。 Helmholtz tells how； as child； he asked his mother to get him the little dolls from the gallery of a very high tower。 I remember myself that at five years I proposed to my comrades to hold my ankles so that I could reach for a ball from the second story of a house down to the court…yard。 I had estimated the height as one…twelfth of its actual magnitude。 Certain standards of under and overestimations are given us when there is near the object to be judged an object the size of which we know。 The reason for the fact that trees and buildings get such ideal sizes on so…called heroic landscape is the artistically reduced scale。 I know that few pictures have made such a devilish impression on me as an enormous landscape； something in the style of Claude Lorraine； covering half a wall。 In its foreground there is to be seen a clerk riding a horse in a glen。 Rider and horse are a few inches high； and because of this the already enormous landscape becomes frightfully big。 I saw the picture as a student； and even now I can describe all its details。 Without the diminutive clerk it would have had no particular effect。
In this connection we must not forget that the relations of magnitude of things about us are； because of perspective； so uncertain that we no longer pay any attention to them。 ‘‘I find it difficult；'' says Lipps；＇1＇ ‘‘to believe that the oven which stands in the corner of the room does not look larger than my hand when I hold it a foot away from my eyes； or that the moon is not larger than the head of a pin； which I look at a little more closely。。。。 We must not forget how we are in the custom of comparing。 I compare hand and oven； and I think of the hand in terms of the oven。'' That is because we know how large the hand and the oven are； but very often we compare things the sizes of which we do not know； or which we can not so easily get at； and then there are many extraordinary illusions。
＇1＇ Die Grundtatsachen des Seelenlebens。 Bonn 1883。
In connection with the cited incident of the estimation of the moon's diameter； there is the illusion of Thomas Reid who saw that the moon seemed as large as a plate when looked at with the unhampered eye； but as large as a dollar when looked at through a tube。 This mistake establishes the important fact that the size of the orifice influences considerably the estimation of the size of object
