gorgias-第12章
按键盘上方向键 ← 或 → 可快速上下翻页，按键盘上的 Enter 键可回到本书目录页，按键盘上方向键 ↑ 可回到本页顶部！
————未阅读完？加入书签已便下次继续阅读！
n lisping； or see him playing like a child； his behaviour appears to me ridiculous and unmanly and worthy of stripes。 And I have the same feeling about students of philosophy； when I see a youth thus engaged…the study appears to me to be in character； and becoming a man of liberal education； and him who neglects philosophy I regard as an inferior man； who will never aspire to anything great or noble。 But if I see him continuing the study in later life； and not leaving off； I should like to beat him； Socrates； for； as I was saying； such a one； even though he have good natural parts； becomes effeminate。 He flies from the busy centre and the market…place； in which； as the poet says； men become distinguished； he creeps into a corner for the rest of his life； and talks in a whisper with three or four admiring you； but never speaks out like a freeman in a satisfactory manner。 Now I； Socrates； am very well inclined towards you； and my feeling may be compared with that of Zethus towards Amphion； in the play of Euripides； whom I was mentioning just now： for I am disposed to say to you much what Zethus said to his brother； that you； Socrates； are careless about the things of which you ought to be careful； and that you
Who have a soul so noble； are remarkable for a puerile exterior； Neither in a court of justice could you state a case； or give any reason or proof； offer valiant counsel on another's behalf。
And you must not be offended； my dear Socrates； for I am speaking out of good…will towards you； if I ask whether you are not ashamed of being thus defenceless； which I affirm to be the condition not of you only but of all those who will carry the study of philosophy too far。 For suppose that some one were to take you； or any one of your sort； off to prison； declaring that you had done wrong when you had done no wrong； you must allow that you would not know what to do：…there you would stand giddy and gaping； and not having a word to say； and when you went up before the Court； even if the accuser were a poor creature and not good for much； you would die if he were disposed to claim the penalty of death。 And yet； Socrates； what is the value of
An art which converts a man of sense into a fool；
who is helpless； and has no power to save either himself or others； when he is in the greatest danger and is going to be despoiled by his enemies of all his goods； and has to live； simply deprived of his rights of citizenship？…he being a man who； if I may use the expression； may be boxed on the ears with impunity。 Then； my good friend； take my advice； and refute no more：
Learn the philosophy of business； and acquire the reputation of wisdom。 But leave to others these niceties；
whether they are to be described as follies or absurdities：
For they will only Give you poverty for the inmate of your dwelling。
Cease； then； emulating these paltry splitters of words； and emulate only the man of substance and honour； who is well to do。 Soc。 If my soul； Callicles； were made of gold； should I not rejoice to discover one of those stones with which they test gold； and the very best possible one to which I might bring my soul； and if the stone and I agreed in approving of her training； then I should know that I was in a satisfactory state； and that no other test was needed by me。 Cal。 What is your meaning； Socrates？ Soc。 I will tell you； I think that I have found in you the desired touchstone。 Cal。 Why？ Soc。 Because I am sure that if you agree with me in any of the opinions which my soul forms； I have at last found the truth indeed。 For I consider that if a man is to make a complete trial of the good or evil of the soul； he ought to have three qualities…knowledge； good…will； outspokenness； which are all possessed by you。 Many whom I meet are unable to make trial of me； because they are not wise as you are； others are wise； but they will not tell me the truth； because they have not the same interest in me which you have； and these two strangers； Gorgias and Polus； are undoubtedly wise men and my very good friends； but they are not outspoken enough； and they are too modest。 Why； their modesty is so great that they are driven to contradict themselves； first one and then the other of them； in the face of a large company； on matters of the highest moment。 But you have all the qualities in which these others are deficient； having received an excellent education； to this many Athenians can testify。 And are my friend。 Shall I tell you why I think so？ I know that you； Callicles； and Tisander of Aphidnae； and Andron the son of Androtion； and Nausicydes of the deme of Cholarges； studied together： there were four of you； and I once heard you advising with one another as to the extent to which the pursuit of philosophy should be carried； and； as I know； you came to the conclusion that the study should not be pushed too much into detail。 You were cautioning one another not to be overwise； you were afraid that too much wisdom might unconsciously to yourselves be the ruin of you。 And now when I hear you giving the same advice to me which you then gave to your most intimate friends； I have a sufficient evidence of your real goodwill to me。 And of the frankness of your nature and freedom from modesty I am assured by yourself； and the assurance is confirmed by your last speech。 Well then； the inference in the present case clearly is； that if you agree with me in an argument about any point； that point will have been sufficiently tested by us； and will not require to be submitted to any further test。 For you could not have agreed with me； either from lack of knowledge or from superfluity of modesty； nor yet from a desire to deceive me； for you are my friend； as you tell me yourself。 And therefore when you and I are agreed； the result will be the attainment of perfect truth。 Now there is no nobler enquiry； Callicles； than that which you censure me for making；…What ought the character of a man to be； and what his pursuits； and how far is he to go； both in maturer years and in youth？ For be assured that if I err in my own conduct I do not err intentionally； but from ignorance。 Do not then desist from advising me； now that you have begun； until I have learned clearly what this is which I am to practise； and how I may acquire it。 And if you find me assenting to your words； and hereafter not doing that to which I assented； call me 〃dolt；〃 and deem me unworthy of receiving further instruction。 Once more； then； tell me what you and Pindar mean by natural justice： Do you not mean that the superior should take the property of the inferior by force； that the better should rule the worse； the noble have more than the mean？ Am I not right in my recollection？ Cal。 Yes； that is what I was saying； and so I still aver。 Soc。 And do you mean by the better the same as the superior？ for I could not make out what you were saying at the time…whether you meant by the superior the stronger； and that the weaker must obey the stronger； as you seemed to imply when you said that great cities attack small ones in accordance with…natural right； because they are superior and stronger； as though the superior and stronger and better were the same； or whether the better may be also the inferior and weaker； and the superior the worse； or whether better is to be defined in the same way as superior： this is the point which I want to have cleared up。 Are the superior and better and stronger the same or different？ Cal。 I say unequivocally that they are the same。 Soc。 Then the many are by nature to the one； against whom； as you were saying； they make the laws？ Cal。 Certainly。 Soc。 Then the laws of the many are the laws of the superior？ Cal。 Very true。 Soc。 Then they are the laws of the better； for the superior class are far better； as you were saying？ Cal。 Yes。 Soc。 And since they are superior； the laws which are made by them are by nature good？ Cal。 Yes。 Soc。 And are not the many of opinion； as you were lately saying； that justice is equality； and that to do is more disgraceful than to suffer injustice？…is that so or not？ Answer； Callicles； and let no modesty be： found to come in the way； do the many think； or do they not think thu
