representative government-第10章
按键盘上方向键 ← 或 → 可快速上下翻页，按键盘上的 Enter 键可回到本书目录页，按键盘上方向键 ↑ 可回到本页顶部！
————未阅读完？加入书签已便下次继续阅读！
urthens would be as light and as judiciously imposed； every branch of administration would be as purely and as intelligently conducted； as the circumstances of the country and its degree of intellectual and moral cultivation would admit。 I am willing； for the sake of the argument； to concede all this； but I must point out how great the concession is； how much more is needed to produce even an approximation to these results than is conveyed in the simple expression； a good despot。 Their realisation would in fact imply； not merely a good monarch； but an all…seeing one。 He must be at all times informed correctly； in considerable detail； of the conduct and working of every branch of administration； in every district of the country； and must be able； in the twenty…four hours per day which are all that is granted to a king as to the humblest labourer； to give an effective share of attention and superintendence to all parts of this vast field； or he must at least be capable of discerning and choosing out； from among the mass of his subjects； not only a large abundance of honest and able men； fit to conduct every branch of public administration under supervision and control； but also the small number of men of eminent virtues and talents who can be trusted not only to do without that supervision； but to exercise it themselves over others。 So extraordinary are the faculties and energies required for performing this task in any supportable manner； that the good despot whom we are supposing can hardly be imagined as consenting to undertake it； unless as a refuge from intolerable evils； and a transitional preparation for something beyond。 But the argument can do without even this immense item in the account。 Suppose the difficulty vanquished。 What should we then have？ One man of superhuman mental activity managing the entire affairs of a mentally passive people。 Their passivity is implied in the very idea of absolute power。 The nation as a whole； and every individual composing it； are without any potential voice in their own destiny。 They exercise no will in respect to their collective interests。 All is decided for them by a will not their own； which it is legally a crime for them to disobey。 What sort of human beings can be formed under such a regimen？ What development can either their thinking or their active faculties attain under it？ On matters of pure theory they might perhaps be allowed to speculate； so long as their speculations either did not approach politics； or had not the remotest connection with its practice。 On practical affairs they could at most be only suffered to suggest； and even under the most moderate of despots； none but persons of already admitted or reputed superiority could hope that their suggestions would be known to； much less regarded by； those who had the management of affairs。 A person must have a very unusual taste for intellectual exercise in and for itself； who will put himself to the trouble of thought when it is to have no outward effect； or qualify himself for functions which he has no chance of being allowed to exercise。 The only sufficient incitement to mental exertion； in any but a few minds in a generation； is the prospect of some practical use to be made of its results。 It does not follow that the nation will be wholly destitute of intellectual power。 The common business of life； which must necessarily be performed by each individual or family for themselves； will call forth some amount of intelligence and practical ability； within a certain narrow range of ideas。 There may be a select class of savants； who cultivate science with a view to its physical uses； or for the pleasure of the pursuit。 There will be a bureaucracy； and persons in training for the bureaucracy； who will be taught at least some empirical maxims of government and public administration。 There may be； and often has been； a systematic organisation of the best mental power in the country in some special direction （commonly military） to promote the grandeur of the despot。 But the public at large remain without information and without interest on all greater matters of practice； or； if they have any knowledge of them； it is but a dilettante knowledge； like that which people have of the mechanical arts who have never handled a tool。 Nor is it only in their intelligence that they suffer。 Their moral capacities are equally stunted。 Wherever the sphere of action of human beings is artificially circumscribed； their sentiments are narrowed and dwarfed in the same proportion。 The food of feeling is action： even domestic affection lives upon voluntary good offices。 Let a person have nothing to do for his country； and he will not care for it。 It has been said of old； that in a despotism there is at most but one patriot； the despot himself； and the saying rests on a just appreciation of the effects of absolute subjection； even to a good and wise master。 Religion remains： and here at least； it may be thought； is an agency that may be relied on for lifting men's eyes and minds above the dust at their feet。 But religion； even supposing it to escape perversion for the purposes of despotism； ceases in these circumstances to be a social concern； and narrows into a personal affair between an individual and his Maker； in which the issue at stake is but his private salvation。 Religion in this shape is quite consistent with the most selfish and contracted egoism； and identifies the votary as little in feeling with the rest of his kind as sensuality itself。 A good despotism means a government in which； so far as depends on the despot； there is no positive oppression by officers of state； but in which all the collective interests of the people are managed for them； all the thinking that has relation to collective interests done for them； and in which their minds are formed by； and consenting to； this abdication of their own energies。 Leaving things to the Government； like leaving them to Providence； is synonymous with caring nothing about them； and accepting their results； when disagreeable； as visitations of Nature。 With the exception； therefore； of a few studious men who take an intellectual interest in speculation for its own sake； the intelligence and sentiments of the whole people are given up to the material interests； and； when these are provided for； to the amusement and ornamentation； of private life。 But to say this is to say； if the whole testimony of history is worth anything； that the era of national decline has arrived： that is； if the nation had ever attained anything to decline from。 If it has never risen above the condition of an Oriental people； in that condition it continues to stagnate。 But if； like Greece or Rome； it had realised anything higher； through the energy； patriotism； and enlargement of mind； which as national qualities are the fruits solely of freedom； it relapses in a few generations into the Oriental state。 And that state does not mean stupid tranquillity； with security against change for the worse； it often means being overrun； conquered； and reduced to domestic slavery； either by a stronger despot； or by the nearest barbarous people who retain along with their savage rudeness the energies of freedom。 Such are not merely the natural tendencies； but the inherent necessities of despotic government； from which there is no outlet； unless in so far as the despotism consents not to be despotism； in so far as the supposed good despot abstains from exercising his power； and； though holding it in reserve； allows the general business of government to go on as if the people really governed themselves。 However little probable it may be； we may imagine a despot observing many of the rules and restraints of constitutional government。 He might allow such freedom of the press and of discussion as would enable a public opinion to form and express itself on national affairs。 He might suffer local interests to be managed； without the interference of authority； by the people themselves。 He might even surround himself with a council or councils of government； freely chosen by the whole or some portion of the nation； retaining in his own hands the power of taxation； and the supreme legislative as well as executive authority。 Were he to act th
